TL;DR
Get gifts for the two of you delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Guillermo Rodriguez and professional partner Witney Carson were eliminated from Dancing with the Stars after the show’s Week 5 Super Bowl-themed episode. Jimmy Kimmel criticized the outcome on Jimmy Kimmel Live, citing the pair’s online views and their latest judges’ score; the available account does not provide the full voting breakdown.
Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson were eliminated from Dancing with the Stars after Tuesday’s Week 5 Super Bowl-themed episode, prompting Jimmy Kimmel to criticize the result on Jimmy Kimmel Live. Kimmel pointed to the pair’s online view counts and their highest judges’ score of the season, while acknowledging that viewer votes had not kept them in the competition.
On his late-night show, Kimmel said Rodriguez and Carson had reached Week 5 and had drawn substantial attention online. He displayed a chart showing 719,000 YouTube views for their performance the previous week, compared with 231,000 for the next-listed pair, Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson. Those figures show the view totals cited in the broadcast; they do not establish how viewers voted on the competition.
Rodriguez and Carson performed a salsa to Bad Bunny during the Super Bowl-themed episode. The judges gave them 22 out of 40 points: Carrie Ann Inaba scored them 6, Derek Hough 5, Joe Buck 6 and Bruno Tonioli 5. Kimmel described that as Rodriguez’s highest score of the season and noted that the pair was again in the bottom two before elimination.
Kimmel also showed clips of news programs supporting Rodriguez and Carson, including broadcasts from the United States and Canada. He then spoke with them backstage. When Kimmel asked whether they would accept the result or take legal action, Rodriguez and Carson jokingly agreed with the latter suggestion. The exchange was presented as humor; there is no indication that either plans to challenge the show’s results.
DWTS • Week 5 Recap
Jimmy Kimmel Slams Voters After Guillermo Rodriguez’s Shocking Elimination
After a Super Bowl-themed salsa and the pair’s highest judges’ score of the season, Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson left Dancing with the Stars. Kimmel questioned the result on Jimmy Kimmel Live, pointing to online attention while the official vote breakdown remained unreported.
The performance & the numbers
A season-best score, then the exit
Rodriguez and Carson danced a salsa to Bad Bunny during the Super Bowl-themed episode. Kimmel called the total Rodriguez’s highest score of the season.
Judges • out of 40
The four judges’ marks add up to the pair’s reported score for the night.
Inaba
Hough
Buck
Tonioli
Prior week • YouTube views shown on Kimmel’s broadcast
Views are not official votes. The account does not provide audience vote totals or the margin between contestants.
What happened
From salsa to backstage banter
Kimmel’s reaction added a late-night audience to the elimination story. The reported sequence shows what happened on the episode and afterward.
Super Bowl salsa
Rodriguez and Carson performed to Bad Bunny during Week 5.
22 points
The judges gave them 22 out of 40, a season high for Rodriguez.
Elimination
The pair landed in the bottom two and were sent home after viewer voting.
Backstage joke
When asked about legal action, they jokingly went along. No serious challenge was reported.
Reading the result
Online attention is not a vote tally
Views show reach
The YouTube figures cited on the broadcast indicate video views, not how many eligible viewers cast a vote.
Judges’ marks are known
The account reports a 22-point score and the individual judges’ marks for this performance.
Breakdown is missing
No vote totals, elimination margin, or detailed scoring-and-voting calculation is included.
“That was his highest score yet and once again, Guillermo was in the bottom two…”
Jimmy Kimmel • on the judges’ score and viewer support“He’s such a sweetheart. He’s so loved by everyone.”
Witney Carson • backstage with Kimmel“Jimmy, I said I was going to lose weight and I did lose weight.”
Guillermo Rodriguez • backstage with KimmelNext on the schedule
The competition continues
“Dedication Night”
The next episode is listed for Tuesday at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and Disney+, with streaming on Hulu the following day.
The available account reports no further response from the show and no formal complaint or legal action. Any claim that the cited views prove the result was unfair goes beyond the information provided.
Online Attention Did Not Secure Votes
The elimination highlights the difference between a performance’s online audience and its standing in a televised dance competition. Kimmel used YouTube views and supportive media coverage to argue that Rodriguez had a devoted following, but those measures do not reveal how many eligible viewers voted or how the show combines audience votes with judges’ scores.
The result also marks the end of a storyline Kimmel had followed publicly throughout the season. His reaction gave the elimination an additional late-night-TV audience, while Carson’s comments underscored the personal connection built through weeks of rehearsals. Still, Kimmel’s criticism is his response to the outcome, not evidence that the voting process was improper.
Dancing with the Stars salsa dance costume
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Rodriguez’s Week Five Run
Rodriguez, known as a Jimmy Kimmel Live personality, competed with Carson as his professional partner. Kimmel had openly supported the pair during their run on Dancing with the Stars, according to the account of his broadcast. He referred to their progress and to the work Carson put into coaching him, describing Rodriguez as someone she had helped develop as a dancer.
The pair had been in the bottom two in an earlier episode as well, Kimmel said, and depended on viewer support to remain in the contest. The reported schedule lists the program as airing Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and Disney+, with episodes available on Hulu the following day. The next episode’s announced theme is “Dedication Night.”
“Last week, Guillermo and Witney had more than triple the YouTube views of their closest opponent.”
— Jimmy Kimmel, on Jimmy Kimmel Live
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Voting Details Remain Unreported
The available account does not give the audience vote totals, the margin between the eliminated pair and other contestants, or a detailed explanation of how judges’ scores and viewer votes determined the result. The YouTube figures Kimmel showed concern video views, not votes, and cannot by themselves establish the level of support in the official tally.
There is also no reported evidence of a formal complaint or legal action. The backstage exchange about suing was joking, and the account does not describe it as a serious plan. Further details about the episode’s full results and voting process are not included.
judge score display board for dance competitions
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Dedication Night Is Next
Dancing with the Stars is scheduled to continue the following Tuesday with “Dedication Night,” airing at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and Disney+. The episode is expected to proceed without Rodriguez and Carson after their elimination. Episodes are listed as streaming on Hulu the next day.
Kimmel’s reaction aired after the results, but no further response from the show or additional information about the vote was reported. The audience totals and judges’ scores remain the concrete figures cited in the account; any claim that they prove the outcome was unfair would go beyond the information available.
Source: Yahoo Entertainment
celebrity performance fan merchandise
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
Who was eliminated from Dancing with the Stars?
Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson were eliminated after the Week 5 Super Bowl-themed episode.
What score did Rodriguez and Carson receive?
The judges gave them 22 out of 40 points: 6 from Carrie Ann Inaba, 5 from Derek Hough, 6 from Joe Buck and 5 from Bruno Tonioli.
Why did Jimmy Kimmel criticize the result?
Kimmel cited the pair’s prior-week YouTube views and Rodriguez’s reported season-high judges’ score. Those points reflected his reaction; the account does not provide official audience vote totals.
Did Rodriguez and Carson say they would take legal action?
They jokingly agreed when Kimmel asked whether they would sue, but no serious legal challenge was reported.
What is the next Dancing with the Stars theme?
The next episode is scheduled to feature “Dedication Night.” The program airs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and Disney+ and is listed for next-day streaming on Hulu.
Source: Yahoo Entertainment
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
